Spring 2006
Instructor: Stewart N. Smith
Class: M, W, & F – 11:00-11:50, 201 Winslow Hall
Office: Winslow Hall, 3rd floor (302-C)
Telephone: 581-3174
E-Mail: stewart.smith@umit.maine.edu
Hours: Tues., Wed. and Fri. 9:00-11:00, or by appointment
We all are involved in processes of growth and change, whether of ourselves, of the human society of which we are a part, or of the natural world around us. We can characterize these processes as development. How we choose to organize these development processes will have a substantive impact on us and on future generations. REP 381, Sustainable development principles and policies, investigates sustainable development as one way to organize our development processes.
Sustainable development (SD) has gained prominence as a development process since the work of the World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED) in the mid-1980s. SD differs from conventional economic development in several ways, including the ethical foundations on which it is based, the implementation processes, and the impacts on stakeholders. REP 381 considers SD in light of these differences, paying particular attention to the ethical basis and the impacts on stakeholders.
The course should provide the student with:
Students will learn how to evaluate a policy or program by SD principles.
The course consists of four distinct blocks. Block one reviews the work of the WCED and the concept of SD. Block two reviews various ethics that can support alternative development processes. Block three surveys the application of SD principles at various levels (global, national, local). Block four applies SD principles to current policy issues. While the segments naturally lead to a comprehensive understanding of SD and the means of assessing it, some students initially may find them disjointed. Keep the faith; it will all come together!
(Block 1): The Genesis of Sustainable Development, or Facing the Problems
We read from the 1987 report of the World Commission on Environment & Development, Our Common Future, to frame the concerns from which recent SD principles are evolving. Lectures will be drawn from this book and other sources.
(Block 2): The Ethical Underpinning, or Determining the Needs and Ability of Current and Future Generations
We then survey selected western ethics to construct a framework that supports a set of SD principles. Preference utilitarianism, social justice, communitarianism, social ecology, deep ecology and ecofeminism are included in this review. We look particularly at their application to intergenerational equity. Most of the readings are from a course pack designed for this course.
(Block 3): Finding Sustainable Development Principles
Third, we survey readings from the Rio Conference (Agenda 21), the President’s Council on Sustainable Development, and Sustainable Maine to note the principles and strategies adopted at the global, national and state levels. We are introduced to a technique for assessing policies and programs according to local sustainable development principles. Most of these readings will be in the course pack.
(Block 4): Policy Assessment
In Block 4, we review alternative perspectives of the “Green Revolution”, and then assess a number of current issues according to SD principles. Issues include domestic agriculture and agricultural research policies, regional forestry policies, Atlantic fisheries policies, and Maine energy policy. Since contemporary legislative and regulatory activities affect these issues, the specific substance will remain somewhat flexible. Readings will be from class handouts as well as the course pack. Since we have guest lecturers in this block, the order of presentations within each topic area indicated in the syllabus may be changed to accommodate their schedules. In this block, students will apply the principles of SD to a team project.
Team Projects: In Block 4 teams of three or four students will analyze selected issues according to SD principles. Each team will make a class presentation and write a team paper due May 1 (executive summaries due April 28). While I allow considerable flexibility of choice, both team composition and topic must be mutually agreed upon.
Grades: Grades are based on:
(10%) Occasional pop quizzes (Pop quizzes can only be made up if you notify me of your absence prior to the quiz or you have valid reason for not doing so.)
(20%) Midterm test covering blocks 1 and 2
(35%) Team projects
(25%) Paper
(10%) Oral Presentation
(35%) Final exam covering the entire course
Quizzes, tests and exams are open book and based on both the assigned readings and class lectures.
Final grades are assigned by letter based on the following numerical values:
A: 93 – 100
B: 84 – 92
C: 75 – 83
D: 65 – 74
E: < 65
Note that this grading scale is not typical for this campus. With open book tests, this scale has worked well for this course.
If you require course adaptations or accommodations because of a disability, please contact the Coordinator for Services for Students with Disabilities, Onward Program at 581-2319.
______________________________________________
Readings
Primary Sources:
World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED), 1987, Our Common Future, Oxford:Oxford University Press.
Course Pack Sustainable Development Principles & Policy, Blocks 2 and 3
Course Pack Sustainable Development Principles & Policy, Block 4
Block 1: The Genesis of Sustainable Development (or Facing the Problems)
Readings from Our Common Future
|
Date / Topics |
Readings |
Pages |
|
Jan. 18 – Preview of Course |
||
|
Jan. 20 – Overview |
Chairman’s Forward |
ix-xv |
|
From One Earth to One World |
1-23 |
|
|
Jan. 23 – Fundamental Problems |
Ch. 1 – A Threatened Future |
27-42 |
|
Basis for Solutions |
Ch. 2 – Towards Sustainable Development |
43-66 |
|
Jan. 25 – International Economy |
Ch. 3 – Role of International Economy |
67-94 |
|
Jan. 27 – Managing the Commons |
Ch. 10 (I & II) |
261-279 |
|
Peace, Security, Development, and the Environment |
Ch. 11 |
290-304 |
|
Jan. 30 – Towards Common Action |
Ch. 12 |
308-343 |
Block 2: An Ethical Underpinning
(or Determining Needs and Ability of Current and Future Generations)
Readings from Course Pack, Blocks 2 & 3
|
Dates / Topics |
Readings |
Pages |
|
Feb. 1,3 |
Freeman |
1-10 |
|
Ch 1. (Preference) Utilitarianism |
Baxter |
11-18 |
|
Feb. 6 – Ch 2. Social (Distributive) Justice |
Sagoff |
21-36 |
|
Feb. 8 – Ch 3. Communitarianism |
Daly & Cobb |
39-55 |
|
Berry |
57-64 |
|
|
Feb. 10 – Ch 5. Deep Ecology |
Devall & Sessions |
81-86 |
|
Feb. 13 – Ch 4. Social Ecology |
Bookchin |
67-78 |
|
Feb. 15 – Ch 6. Ecofeminism |
Warren |
89-100 |
|
Shiva |
101-107 |
|
|
Feb. 17 – Ch 7. Role of Technology |
Hardin |
111-116 |
|
Simon |
117-122 |
|
|
Feb. 20 – REVIEW |
||
|
Feb. 22 – MID-TERM |
Block 3: Finding Sustainable Development Principles
Readings from Course Pack, Blocks 2 & 3 & handouts
|
Dates / Topic |
Readings |
Pages |
|
Feb. 24 – Ch. 8. Global Strategies |
Sitarz – Agenda 21 |
125-156 |
|
Feb. 27 – Ch. 9. National Strategies |
PCSD – Sustainable America |
159-200 |
|
State Strategies |
Sustainable Maine |
Handout |
|
Mar. 1,3 – S.D. Assessment Technique |
Smith et al. |
Handout |
|
Mar. 6 – 17 |
SPRING BREAK |
|
|
Mar. 20, 22 – S.D. Assessment Technique |
Smith et al. |
Handout |
Block 4: Policy Assessment
Readings from Course Pack Block 4 and handouts
|
Dates / Topic |
Readings |
Pages |
|
Mar. 24, 27, 29 – The Green Revolution: Global Perspective |
Wolf |
1-18 |
|
Hazell & Ramasamy |
19-26 |
|
|
Pearse |
27-37 |
|
|
Mar. 31, Apr. 3, 5 – Policy #1 – Domestic Food & Agriculture |
Smith & Marra |
39-49 |
|
Urban |
51-53 |
|
|
Mar. 31 – Lecture |
Handouts |
|
|
Apr. 3 – Guest |
||
|
Apr. 5 – Student Teams |
||
|
Apr. 7, 10, 12 – Policy #2 – U.S./Regional Forestry Policy |
Santiago Agreement |
55-58 |
|
Seymour et al. |
59-62 |
|
|
Apr. 7 – Lecture |
Lansky |
63-81 |
|
Apr. 10 – Guest |
Handouts |
|
|
Apr. 12 – Student Teams |
||
|
Apr. 14, 17, 19 – Policy #3 – Atlantic Fisheries |
Townsend |
83-89 |
|
Wilson |
91-95 |
|
|
Apr. 14 – Lecture |
Handouts |
|
|
Apr. 17 – Guest |
||
|
Apr. 19 – Student Teams |
||
|
Apr. 21 – Student Teams |
||
|
Apr. 24 – Policy #4: Sustainable Communities |
Handouts |
|
|
Apr. 26, 28 – Policy #5 – Energy |
Handouts |
|
|
Apr 26 – Guest |
||
|
Apr. 28 – Lecture |
||
|
Apr. 28 – Project Executive Summaries due |
||
|
May 1 – Student Project Papers Due |
||
|
Overview |
||
|
May 3 – Maine Day – no class |
||
|
May 5 – Review |
May 8 (Monday): Final Exam: 10:30 a.m. – 12:30. WW 201.